The Distance

The Distance

'Better Than You': Karl Marx Would Recognize Transgenderism As A Material Class

Make the enemy play by his own set of rules

Matt Osborne's avatar
Matt Osborne
Dec 05, 2022
∙ Paid
Karl Marx - Imgflip

Karl Marx is a tool.

No, relax, I am not insulting the great prophet of communism, peace be upon him.

I am describing the use of Marx to understand history.

For all his faults, Marx knew what a woman is. In fact, dimorphic biology was the fundamental unit of capitalism in his analysis: woman as the first property, a reality of his 19th Century world, seemingly a thing as old as time, at a time when literal people-as-property was still a thing in the “civilized world,” and people struggled to imagine a different world.

A better world.

Feminists like Marxist analysis because it works very well for analyzing patriarchy to imagine a better world.

For example, radical feminists were the very first people to call out the contradictions inherent to transgenderism, earning the sobriquet “TERFs” by resisting a male colonization of feminism.

Analyzing “trans women are women” as a material sex class phenomenon, they saw patriarchy putting on lipstick and wigs and calling it progressive. TERFs have b…

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Matt Osborne.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 LGB United · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture